Liberia: Three Bowls, One Pot: Liberia’s 2027 Budget

In our family home, each person had three bowls: one for soup, one for cassava, and one for rice. There were days when we received all three. On other days, there were two—cassava and soup—or only one, holding dry rice.

Must read

By George K. Werner (former education minister)

Before I knew what a national budget was, I knew the difference between having a bowl and having something in it.

In our family home, each person had three bowls: one for soup, one for cassava, and one for rice. There were days when we received all three. On other days, there were two—cassava and soup—or only one, holding dry rice.

The bowls remained ours even when there was less to put in them.

As Momma dished up, one of my siblings watched keenly. He followed the portions into each person’s bowls and complained when he thought someone was receiving more. Sometimes Momma made adjustments. Other times, she ignored him.

I cannot now account for every decision she made. My sibling could see what had been served. Momma also had to know what remained.

Years later, leading Liberia’s Civil Service Agency and then its Ministry of Education, I encountered requests that exceeded the money available to meet them. Each came with a reason. Behind many were people who had already waited too long. I came to understand something of the difficulty of holding the serving spoon.

I also understood why someone would watch.

That memory returns as Liberia considers its proposed 2027 national budget of approximately US$1.539 billion. Finance Minister Augustine Ngafuan says spending entities requested about US$3 billion. Submitted to the Legislature on November 6, the proposal carries almost twice as much expressed demand as it has resources to satisfy.

But scarcity is only part of the story. The other part is how much the budget has grown.

Under President Ellen Johnson Sirleaf, the approved national budget for fiscal year 2016/17 was US$600.2 million. The proposed 2027 budget is about 2.56 times that amount in nominal dollars. That compares an approved historical budget with a proposal, not actual spending in either year. Nevertheless, the scale of the increase deserves attention.

We worked within those earlier constraints. We also left much unfinished. I invoke that period with an awareness of my own responsibilities, not as a claim that services were adequate then.

The question is what Liberians should expect from the additional resources now.

If more food became available in our home and the portions remained unchanged, my sibling would surely have watched Momma’s spoon more closely.

A growing national budget deserves at least that much scrutiny.

Are households receiving more dependable electricity from the Liberia Electricity Corporation? Is the Liberia Water and Sewer Corporation reaching more homes with reliable water and sanitation services?

Can a patient obtain care without relatives having to search elsewhere for essential supplies? Can parents depend on a public school to educate their children? Are young people finding work that allows them to support themselves?

These questions require evidence. They should guide the budget debate as firmly as the revenue projections do.

A fair comparison across a decade must account for changes in prices, population, debt obligations, and what the budget includes. We must also distinguish an appropriation from money actually collected and spent. A larger nominal budget does not automatically mean a proportionately larger amount available for each person’s needs.

But those qualifications should lead to a clearer account of results. What has the additional money purchased? Where have services improved? Where have they failed to keep pace, and why?

Several proposed allocations show the competing claims on public resources:

Allocation| Proposed 2027 amount

National Legislature| US$58.20 million

Education sector overall| US$163.55 million

Ministry of Education—included within the education sector| US$68.04 million

Health sector overall| US$135.83 million

Ministry of Health—included within the health sector| US$95.60 million

Debt service, as described in the budget preface| US$275.49 million

These are selected allocations, not a complete expenditure breakdown. Ministry amounts are included in their sector totals. Debt service comprises interest and other charges together with payments against domestic and foreign liabilities.

Each amount needs an explanation of what it will deliver.

For electricity, the account should include reliability, connections, losses, collections, and the cost of supplying power. For water, it should include functioning connections, continuity of supply, and maintenance. Utility performance must be assessed alongside customer revenue, investment, and management—not through national budget allocations alone.

For education, we should know what it costs to provide a functioning school and whether the allocation meets that cost. For health, we should know what each category of facility is expected and funded to provide.

For employment, we must look beyond government recruitment. Does public spending help businesses operate, invest, and hire? Do training programs equip young people for work that exists? Are roads, electricity, and other services making it easier to earn a living?

The national budget cannot promise every person a job. It should explain how its choices improve the conditions in which jobs can be created.

My experience in government taught me how easily an allocation can be mistaken for an answer. A request receives a line in the budget, and there is relief. Yet the amount may be insufficient, the release uncertain, or the resources needed to make it useful unfunded.

A school building must open into a working school day. Someone must teach. Children need materials. Water must be available. Repairs must happen before a small defect becomes a reason to close a classroom.

A clinic needs staff, medicines, supplies, electricity, and a way to refer patients whose care exceeds its capacity. When an essential part is missing, the burden falls on the person who arrived expecting help.

This is why recurrent expenditure should be examined carefully rather than dismissed. A teacher must be paid repeatedly because children must be taught repeatedly. Medicines need replenishing. Maintenance must continue long after the photograph of a completed project has been taken.

The proposed budget includes compensation measures expected to benefit more than 17,000 people through salary improvements and recruitment, including the regularization of volunteers. Fair pay matters. So does financing the supplies and working conditions that enable employees to serve the public.

Legislative hearings should establish whether these components have been funded together. Technical and vocational education, for example, requires equipment, consumables, and practical instruction, including in programs administered outside the Ministry of Education. A salary allocation alone cannot provide them.

When essential services remain incomplete, the obligation often travels into a household.

A parent buys what the school lacks. A patient pays for supplies. A family pays to reach a more distant facility. Where money cannot be found, someone may go without.

This helps explain why a larger public budget can coexist with persistent hardship. Families judge improvement partly by what they no longer have to struggle to provide for themselves. If public spending grows while those burdens remain, the figures will offer little reassurance.

We should also know what will happen if projected revenue falls short. Which services will be protected? Which purchases can wait? And after passage, citizens must be able to follow the money from approval to release, from release to the institution, and from the institution to the promised service.

My sibling’s scrutiny was immediate. He could speak while an adjustment was still possible. Public expenditure travels farther, through offices and decisions that most citizens cannot see. Reporting should make that journey easier to follow.

Those allocating resources must also listen beyond the loudest complaints. A remote community may have no delegation in Monrovia. A family struggling through the week may lack the means to pursue an unanswered request. Silence tells us little about whether someone has enough.

Momma sometimes changed the portions. Lawmakers should likewise be willing to revise allocations when evidence reveals an overlooked need, an unjustified expense, or a service that cannot function on what it has been given.

A larger pot gives us more possibilities. It also gives us more to account for.

I still remember those three bowls, and the days when we received only two or one. The number of bowls told us what we hoped for. What Momma could put into them told us what we would actually eat.

As lawmakers examine the 2027 budget, they should keep that distinction in mind. Every allocation carries an expectation. The responsibility is to put enough behind it to deliver.

Latest article